Hunting and Wildlife Magazine - Issue 229 - Winter 2025
Words By: Simon Carkeek
For generations, the mantra ‘walk it off’ has echoed through New Zealand’s hunting and tramping communities. Whether it was a rolled ankle or a bruised knee, the prevailing wisdom was to grit your teeth and carry on. Interestingly, current research now supports this approach, in part. While some movement can help recovery in minor soft tissue injuries, it's critical to assess severity first.
Soft tissue injuries: The most likely trip-stopper
According to the New Zealand Mountain Safety Council (NZMSC), soft tissue injuries - like sprains, strains, and bruises - are the most common injuries for recreational hunters. In fact, slips, trips and falls account for nearly half of all hunting incidents (NZMSC, 2017).
These aren’t always dramatic accidents - it’s the rolled ankle halfway down a ridge or the awkward slide on wet clay. And while many of these injuries seem minor, mismanaging them can mean an early end to your trip or, worse, long-term damage.
The fall of RICE and what replaces it
For years, the go-to advice for injury management was RICE: Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation. Introduced by Dr. Gabe Mirkin in 1978, it became gospel in sports medicine circles. But in 2015, Mirkin himself publicly retracted it, stating that suppressing inflammation with ice and excessive rest can actually delay healing (Mirkin, 2015).
Despite this, the New Zealand Resuscitation Council still endorses RICE as best practice. However, if we look internationally at evidence-based guidelines from near-peer countries like Canada, the UK, and parts of Australia, the shift is clear - modern protocols favour early movement, progressive loading, and patient education over prolonged rest and icing.
Today’s best practice and evidence-based advice support early, gentle movement in most minor injuries - think walking it off if you can do so without limping or worsening symptoms. Protocols like PEACE & LOVE (Protection, Elevation, Avoid anti-inflammatories, Compression, Education / Load, Optimism, Vascularisation, Exercise) encourage active recovery and smart decision-making. Staying completely still, in many cases, does more harm than good.
When to keep moving and when to stop
Controlled movement is good - but only if it’s not making things worse. Key red flags that should make you stop immediately are:
-
Can’t bear weight at all
-
Significant swelling or bruising appears quickly
-
Any deformity, crunching sensation, or ’pop’ felt
-
Numbness, tingling, or loss of function.
In those cases, assume that there has been a fracture or a more serious soft tissue injury and immobilise the limb via positioning - for example, placing gear around the limb to support it in a comfortable position for the patient. Do not attempt to splint unless you’ve been trained to do so. If the person can’t move safely and help is a long way off, be prepared to escalate, which may include activating emergency signalling equipment.
That’s all well and good for general advice, but the realities of the backcountry make this more nuanced. If you’re considering ‘walking it off’, make sure you’ve thought through the practicalities of your egress. A lower limb soft tissue injury might seem manageable at the time, but if your exit involves steep terrain, scree slopes, river crossings, or dense bush, it may quickly become unmanageable. Reassess whether pushing on is safe for both you and your group. If your footing is compromised or you’re at risk of aggravating the injury or putting others in danger, stopping and signalling for help may be the smarter call.
Plan as if you are on your own
Even a simple sprain can become a serious problem if you're several hours from help with no signal. That’s why carrying a Personal Locator Beacon (PLB) is essential, not optional. A good quality PLB fits in a jacket pocket or bino harness and, when activated, sends your exact location to search and rescue.
Make sure it’s registered, and like a tourniquet, ensure it’s carried on your person, not buried in your pack. Everyone in your group should know how to use it. Activating a PLB early, especially for immobile injuries, can save lives.
Key takeaways for the bush
-
Soft tissue injuries are the most common incident in NZ hunting
-
RICE is outdated - early, gentle movement is now recommended where safe
-
If in doubt, treat it as a fracture
-
Always carry a PLB - and know how to use it
When you're hours from help, how you handle an injury can make or break the outcome. It’s not about being soft - it’s about being smart. Walk it off if you can. But know when to stop, stabilise, and call for help.
www.pracmednz.com 0800 113 992
Read Hunting & Wildlife Magazine
NZDA members receive an electronic version by email, and can access it on the NZDA app. Subscriptions and physical copies can be purchased online. Visit the NZDA Shop at www.nzda.shop
Missed an issue?
We make our older editions free to read online. Browse the back catalogue here.
Write for Hunting and Wildlife
